Friday, June 10, 2011

Indian Democracy

I am a very confused - Who is Anna Hazare, I don’t remember electing him to represent me, so I asked my friends and neighbours and no one had elected him or others in his team….so who is he? And who constitutes civil society that Anna, kejriwal, Bhusan father and son duo are representing. Am not part of any political party or an elected representative so by elimination am part of the Civil Society and so is 90+% of this country’s 1.2 BN people. If Anna and team are representing over a billion people and the sum total of all political parties represent < less than 10%, then by the definition of democracy and majority representation – Anna and team should be governing the country.. hence am confused as to why are they not?

And who is Ramdev? He also claims to represent me, but again I can’t remember electing him, I do remember seeing him on TV collapsing, expanding his belly sometimes. I hear that he mobilized some 65000 of in Delhi to demand something on my behalf…but I cant remember every asking them to do so.

I remember, from school text books and teachings of some very bored teachers of those days that our founding fathers chose the parliamentary form of democracy, wherein everyone (irrespective of caste, language, color sex..) after attaining a certain age has the fundamental right to elect her/his representative to various assemblies be it at the centre (Delhi) or state, or local bodies like municipal or panchayats. Which will result in the formation of a government chosen by the majority of Indians and further that all the elected representatives will meet regularly in an assembly to discuss, oppose, agree, disagree in formations of policies and rules for governing the country. Also there are four estates of ensuring checks and balance in a democracy viz Legislature, Civil Servants, Judiciary and Press; with freedom of expression guaranteed as fundamental right for all citizens.

And so we did, every five or lesser number of years we have been continuously reposing faith in the democratic process, knowing very well that democracy and its structures are not the best form of governance, but in spite of all its failures is still the best amongst all the known representation and governance forms as of now.

But now Anna and team and collapsing/expanding belly is telling me that we screwed up, we are fools , we don’t know what is right and wrong for us and hence they will represent us and fight the people elected by us and are asking me to join the fight for second FREEDOM???

Now am completely bewildered, once again from early school days we learnt that we got freedom from colonial powers so that we can administer our own country, make policies for our ownselves.... but Anna and team are saying that I have to join in freedom struggle to fight against the people we all elected? Expanding/collapsing belly is even asking to me join in an armed struggle.

They are holding satyagraha and fast-unto-death to fight the elected government.

Kejriwal says that if Manmohan Singh is honest then why is he scared of being included within the ambit of Lok Pal, someone needs to tell him that Manmohan Singh is a Prime Minster, Prime Minister is not Manmohan Singh – it’s a role

They started with fight against corruption and claimed they are representing me in the fight, but I am wondering that Father Bhusan was a cabinet rank minister once, why is it that he did not promulgate the laws then or influence his colleagues then….when we know that corruption in India is as old as free India or even more.

They started with fight against corruption, which I understood but then they seem to be only interested in sitting with elected representatives and enjoy the pleasure of jointly drafting a Lok Pal bill, but they did not discuss with me the provisions of that bill, they want to include Prime Minister and Chief Justice within the ambit of Lok Pal, but again I don’t remember they asking me if I wanted this to happen.

Even if they do not ask me, I still want to express my view – while I deplore the corruption at the highest level but the corruption at the lowest level of cops, sub-registrars, government clerks which makes my daily life intolerable and Anna and team is suggesting that Lok Pal – who once again will be nominated – will be more honest than the Prime Minister and Chief Justice of the country…how can I be assured that Lok Pal who would come from the society that all of us including elected representatives and judiciary come from will be more honest; I at least have the right to throw the government in every election, but how will I participate in selection of Lok Pal?; And how can i trust a civil service person, when my experience and trust at lowest level is dismal and I have no say in their appointments and transfers..

Lets assume for a moment that current government has done nothing to arrest corruption which has plagued the Indian society since time immemorial (even though I don’t remember any past and current state governments like BJP in Karnataka – allowing the democratic institutions to function freely and prosecute even cabinet rank ministers and also landing some high and mighty in a jail, but Manmohan Singh as Prime Minster did allow and even enabled it to happen)still, SHAME on the current government that while they did enabled some wonderful economic decisions for the growth of the country as well as working hard to push the growing prosperity to the weakest in the country (NREGA and other social benefit schemes or even RTE), also introduced RTI to bring transparency in administration, failed to promulgate policies to stem the virus of corruption that has been around since days of independence.

BUT BIGGER SHAME on representatives of other parties like BJP, whose role as opposition is to be a watchdog on government functioning and policy making, why is it that they have to hold the tails of Anna’s and Ramdev’s to raise their voice, what they did they do to curb corruption when they had formed the government, what have they done in Karnataka – which is now known to be one of the most corrupt state, where there is known rampant corruption right upto the level of Chief Minister – So bigger SHAME on them.

Shame on the local government to crack down on some peaceful protesters and leaving even one completely paralyzed, but equally culpable in this guilt is Baba Ramdev for influencing innocent and gullible people to participate in a rally which was meant to further his cause of political interests or even getting bigger TV bites

As citizen of a democratic India, my message to Anna and team, Ramdev and cohorts is simple :

  • I do not think any Indian political party can have claims to higher moral values than the other, BUT I still believe in Democracy and freedom to exercise my choice
  • By turning the fight against corruption to a fight against just the central government, you are legitimizing the corrupt practices of state governments, government officials at various levels from clerks to secerataries, and diffusing the purpose of this agitation
  • Street protests against an elected government may not be the best form of influencing government functioning, we are not Egypt or Tunisia, we have elected representatives and instiutions to influence the governance. Look at NAC, comprising social activists like you who have played significant role in policy framing towards social benefit schemes such as NREGA or even the currently debated one on subsidized grains. There are serious disagreements and debates with some public posturing and voicing, but by staying away from street brawls, populist statements like "fight for 2nd freedom" and statying away from the glare TV and 24x7 news reporting...they have been able to achieve wonderful results within the democratic framework
  • The biggest difference between the previous several governments that I have seen and the current one is that they are willing to accept corruption is a problem and are willing to let the enforcement agencies and judiciary to function irrespective of the status of the person, thereby set a precedence as well as send out a strong message that corruption at any level will not be tolerated. One may argue that it was the CAG report that nailed the 2G scam, but remember letting CAG function as an independent constitutional body and not scuttle its functioning or reporting the scam is a credit due to the current government led by Manmohan Singh
  • Please do not always assume that you know what is better for me
  • Please do not represent me without asking me
  • Its very easy to get heady with street protests and seeing some thousands assembling
  • BUT please do not tell me you are fighting a freedom struggle
  • If you are mobilizing opinion against corruption then I support you, provided we dont reduce this to a fight against one elected government, thereby silently legitimize the corrupt functioning of other politicans, parties, local governments and officials., provided we dont make this just as a media event, we include other notable people (like the ones in NAC or other luminaries - judicial/non-judicial of this country) and make it a larger participative debate (even a refrendum), remembering that we do not want to create a dysfuntional governance model, remembering that 5 individuals of civil society and few cabinet ministers may not represent the larger demos of India.Also Lok Pal bill may not be the ultimate panacea against corruption, there has to be a sustained social campaign resulting in it being made a know social stigma
  • I fear that by reducing this campaign to just fight a government and lok bal bill, we will not achieve the objective of  making India corruption free
  • I BELIEVE IN DEMOCRACY
  • I BELIEVE IN MANMOHAN SINGH
Anupam